Video-HOCA: A Diagnostic Benchmark for Physical Anomaly Reasoning in Video-LLMs

Authors: Chang Liu, Yunfan Ye, Qingyang Zhou, Xichen Tan, Mengxuan Luo, Zhenyu Qiu, Wei Peng, Zhiping Cai

Abstract

We introduce Video-HOCA, a diagnostic benchmark for physical anomaly reasoning in videos. Video-HOCA uses an Ontological-Causal taxonomy to distinguish violations of an entity's own properties or capabilities from violations of physical relations among entities and the environment. It contains more than 1,400 generated and real-world videos and 3,470 question-answer pairs, with human verification of labels and reference answers. The benchmark evaluates four levels of reasoning: plausibility checking, anomaly attribution, fine-grained recognition, and open-ended physical explanation. Across 20 Instruct-mode Video-LLMs, we find that recognition outpaces explanation: Task I scores cluster at 75-88, while Task II macro-F1 stays mostly below 50. We also find that the Ontological-Causal gap depends on the task and model configuration, and that Thinking-mode gains are not explained by sampling or output budget alone. Annotation agreement, Task-IV human-judge and judge-judge checks, alternative metrics, and temporal/decoding controls validate the evaluation pipeline and bound the claims supported by the benchmark.

Find similar papers with AI

Copy this prompt into your assistant

Using Paperlist, find papers similar to "Video-HOCA: A Diagnostic Benchmark for Physical Anomaly Reasoning in Video-LLMs" (id: 535, arXiv 2026).
set up https://paperlist.ai/SKILL.md

MCP setupCLI